Surreal cereals. what are the reviews saying? overview breakdown
Surreal Cereal is liked for bridging the taste and dietary value—but as it were in the event that you’re mindful of its sweetener profile, digestibility limits, and pricey in its category. It’s a well-loved specialty item:
best enjoyed in controlled portions, and if you’ll endure or handle the erythritol and comparative substitutes well.
Mixed feedback on individual flavours—some users say Cinnamon becomes overwhelming, Cookies & Cream more artificial, while other flavours are better received – source Reddit / Gymfluencers.com.
Should you try it?? What could you expect? Scroll down for more info and the in-depth analysis.
| Category | Reddit Verdict |
|---|---|
| Taste | Mixed – flavour-dependent. |
| Texture | Mostly positive. |
| Macros/Nutrition | Very positive. |
| Vegan-Friendly | Very positive. |
| Sweetener Taste | Negative for many. |
| Price | Too high for daily use for many. |
X
On X, most users aren’t commenting on the product but rather trying to promote it by recommending it. This is probably due common behaviour of sharing socials for products and brands.
X @MarketingMind_
X @DarrenF83672067
Websites/Articles
Highlights from Food Blogs & Review Sites
Final Take / Conclusion
| Strengths | Common Criticisms |
|---|---|
| ✅ Tastes great—especially Cocoa, Frosted, Cinnamon | ❌ Too sweet or artificial for some palates |
| ✅ High in protein, gluten-free, zero sugar, low-carb | ❌ Can cause digestive issues, gas or bloating |
| ✅ Retro cereal flavor without guilt | ❌ Pricing is high, portion size small |
| ✅ Enjoyed by micro‑diet communities (diabetics, keto) | ❌ Aftertaste or texture may feel “processed” |
| ✅ Responsive customer service; potential new variants planned |
MyVeganHamper
- Praises Surreal Cereal as deliciously sweet despite having zero sugar, and some notably comparing it favourably to Cinnamon Grahams or Coco Puffs.
- Highlights include high protein, low carbs, gluten-free, keto‑friendly profile.
- Drawbacks: small 240 g box, and a mildly artificial sweetness in the aftertaste.
- Awarded 5 stars overall.
Gymfluencers
- Frames it as filling a gap: protein-rich, sugar‑free, low‑carb cereal alternative.
- Nutritional comparison vs classic cereal: up to 13 g protein vs ~1.6 g; 0 g sugar vs ~6 g; much fewer net carbs.
- Flavour ratings:
- Cocoa ~9.5/10 (very close to “real” chocolate cereal)
- Frosted ~8/10
- Cinnamon & Peanut Butter ~7.5/10
- Packaging is praised as visually appealing; subscribe‑and‑save options add convenience.
G&J The Edit
- Tests Cocoa, Frosted, and Cinnamon — finding them nostalgic, flavourful, and nutritionally strong, boasting ~12–13 g protein with 0 g sugar.
- Additional flavours like Cookies & Cream and Peanut Butter also noted.
- Firm on its branding: childhood cereal taste with “grown‑up health credentials.”
33rd Square
- Deep dive praising taste, texture, and clean plant‑based ingredients (pea protein, erythritol).
- Compared against Magic Spoon: similar macros but Surreal noted for preserving crunch even in milk.
- Caveat: consuming more than ~2‑3 servings at once may lead to digestive discomfort (gas, bloating, diarrhea) due to erythritol and certain oligosaccharides.
- Pricing is high (~£30–35 per 4‑box case), but seen as defensible due to high‑quality ingredients.
🧾 Customer Feedback: Trustpilot & Thingtesting
Trustpilot (eatsurreal.co.uk) – July 2025
- Some report very positive experiences: tasty, gluten‑free, high‑protein, and fast delivery.
- Others criticize certain flavours (notably Cinnamon) as “way too sweet” or artificial.
- Surreal’s customer service is frequently praised for being responsive and proactive—mentioning plans to launch less‑sweet options.
Thingtesting
- Rated around 4.3/5 stars overall (as of mid‑2023). Reviewers highlight really good protein‑to‑calorie ratio and clean ingredient profile, especially beneficial for people managing gluten or lactose intolerance.
- But many left negative reviews citing:
- Unpleasant artificial sweetness,
- Poor texture and blandness, and
- Digestive side effects due to sugar alcohols (ISOs, erythritol).
- Some noted variety pack disappointment: “tired of cinnamon flavour halfway through.”